Latest News

2010 FEEDBACK TO ENTRANTS
28/04/2010


The Martin Wills Awards are now in their 18th year and as Chairman of the judges I wanted to thank you for entering and to make some points about your actual writing which I hope that you will take as “Constructive Criticism”. I know that’s a doom-laden phrase, but I promise I mean it in the positive sense.

First, the good news: the overall entry of 169 equalled last year’s record, the Under 26 entry of 82 was a record, and all 22 on the shortlist were well worthy of that  category. With fewer than 1 in 7 overall making the cut, to be shortlisted itself was quite an achievement, and a number of other entrants, especially in the Under 26 category, came close to making the list.

In the Under 26 division, the judges were impressed by the quality and diversity of subject matter on the shortlist.  In the younger categories, the Under 15s were more impressive overall than the Under 19s. However, both produced a good number or original and entertaining articles.
 
Now the bad news  - or rather what, as judges, we feel we ought to give you as  that “Constructive Criticism “  We felt that the overall standard of the 169 entries was a little disappointing compared to recent years. Too many entries were, to be blunt, rather boring. Very few showed any great flights of imagination or the inclination to come at the sport from an unusual angle. We felt this to be a shame as racing, more than any other sport, embraces such a wide variety of possibilities  -  people and horses,  hope and disaster, physical excitement, financial challenge and sometimes despair.

Too many entries relied on clichés about racing , and this year too many seemed to feel that dumping their thoughts in the  Racing for Change bran-tub might somehow prove a winning system,  whereas the form book for this competition tells us that racing politics usually make for very dull reading. This year there was also a surfeit of articles about Kauto Star – a pretty obvious topic – although I am glad to say the spate of pieces about equine fatalities spawned by Best Mate’s unhappy demise does seem to have dropped off a bit.

In the senior category, and to a lesser extent in the two younger categories, too many of the entries gave purple prose priority over structure and clarity. The judges are not expecting to uncover budding Amises on every page and it is usually best to keep the language simple – Hugh McIlvanney does and he has done OK!

And then there is presentation. Whilst we don’t expect every entry to be 100% perfect (even seasoned hacks need subbing), anyone entering these sorts of competitions should realise that errors in spelling, punctuation and grammar can irritate enough to bias judgement. You should note that sticking on “Spell Check” is no substitute for reading the whole thing through at least twice and, best of all if you can find someone, to read it through to a sympathetic listener. Believe me, I do it almost every time (the assorted listeners are getting pretty fed up), but the reading-out- loud process invariably shows up all sorts of mistakes and infelicities – I am actually doing it now.

Also a single slab of unparagraphed prose is a real turn off to most readers and practically all judges. In my experience the only journalist who got away with this was the late, great Bernard Levin and even he was an acquired taste. My one overriding tip to you all is to have written above your desk, on your laptop, or preferably programmed in your brain, the phrase “Think of the Reader.” If you keep thinking of him or her, all the other things have to fall into place.

Beyond that, we would like, as judges, to suggest that future entrants concentrate on the criteria set out clearly in the fifth paragraph of the Press Release : “Particular importance will be attached by the judges to originality, imagination, conviction, entertainment, construction, and use of language.” That may be quite a mouthful (not to mention a touch of “too many ‘ions’. Ed”) but it should be real food for thought, as should be reading the feedback for the three previous years (especially 2007) which is included in the news section of the Martin Wills Awards Website.

I hope you get some of the points I am trying to make and I would like to sign off by thanking you most sincerely for taking part – I know how tough it is to actually get down to do this and have great admiration for all 169 of you. I hope that you have enjoyed the experience and that, if eligible, you will have another crack next year.

Brough Scott
Chairman of the judges

2017 MARTIN WILLS WRITING AWARDS TO BE 25th AND LAST
12 August 2016
JUDGES REPORT TO 2016 ENTRANTS
21 June 2016
WINNERS OF 24th MARTIN WILLS WRITING AWARDS ANNOUNCED
13 April 2016
MESSAGE TO PRIZE-WINNERS 1993-2015
22 March 2016
JOINT RECORD ENTRY FOR 2016 MARTIN WILLS WRITING AWARDS
11 February 2016
2016 MARTIN WILLS WRITING AWARDS FINAL REMINDER ENTRIES CLOSE ON 31 JANUARY
16 January 2016
ENTRIES FOR 24TH MARTIN WILLS WRITING AWARDS CLOSE ON 31 JANUARY
04 January 2016
JUDGES’ FEEDBACK ON THE 2015 ENTRY
21 October 2015
24TH MARTIN WILLS WRITING AWARDS ANNOUNCED
25 September 2015
WINNERS OF 23RD WILLS WRITING AWARDS ANNOUNCED
15 April 2015
SIR MARK PRESCOTT TO PRESENT 23rd WILLS WRITING AWARDS
06 February 2015
23rd WILLS WRITING AWARDS
09 January 2015
Feedback on 2014 Wills Writing Awards
02 December 2014
Video Interview - 2014 Winners
20 May 2014
WINNERS OF 22nd WILLS WRITING AWARDS ANNOUNCED
16 April 2014
140 ENTRIES FOR 2014 WILLS WRITING AWARDS – JILLY COOPER TO PRESENT PRIZES
03 March 2014
JILLY COOPER SUPPORTS 22ND WILLS WRITING AWARDS
03 February 2014
22nd WILLS WRITING AWARDS
03 January 2014
FEEDBACK ON 2013 WILLS WRITING AWARDS
17 May 2013
WINNERS OF 21st ANNIVERSARY WILLS WRITING AWARDS ANNOUNCED
17 April 2013
ENTRIES CLOSED FOR 2013 WILLS WRITING AWARDS
05 March 2013
CLOSING DATE FOR WRITING AWARDS FOR YOUNG PEOPLE
08 February 2013
21st ANNIVERSARY WILLS WRITING AWARDS
04 January 2013
FEEDBACK ON 2012 WILLS WRITING AWARDS
17 December 2012
WINNERS OF 20th ANNIVERSARY WILLS WRITING AWARDS ANNOUNCED
18 April 2012
ENTRIES FOR 2012 WILLS WRITING AWARDS
06 March 2012
CLOSING DATE FOR WRITING AWARDS FOR YOUNG PEOPLE
10 February 2012
20th ANNIVERSARY WILLS WRITING AWARDS
06 January 2012
2011 MESSAGE TO ENTRANTS
21 November 2011
2011 WINNERS OF HORSERACING WRITING AWARDS FOR YOUNG PEOPLE ANNOUNCED
13 April 2011
ENTRIES FOR 2011 WILLS WRITING AWARDS CLOSED
03 March 2011
2011 CLOSING DATE FOR WRITING AWARDS
11 February 2011
2011 WRITING AWARDS FOR UNDER 26s UNDER19s UNDER 15s
07 January 2011
2010 FEEDBACK TO ENTRANTS
28 April 2010
WINNERS OF HORSERACING WRITING AWARDS FOR YOUNG PEOPLE ANNOUNCED
14 April 2010
WILLS WRITING AWARDS 2010 SHORTLIST CHOSEN
17 March 2010
RECORD-EQUALLING ENTRY FOR WILLS WRITING AWARDS
05 March 2010
WRITE-UP!
05 February 2010
A CHALLENGE TO YOUNG WRITERS
04 February 2010
2010 WRITING AWARDS FOR UNDER 26s UNDER19s UNDER 15s
09 January 2010
ADVANCE NOTICE TO SCHOOLS OF WRITING AWARDS FOR UNDER 19s/15s
12 October 2009
FEEDBACK TO ENTRANTS OF THE 2009 WILLS WRITING AWARDS
31 May 2009
WINNERS OF HORSERACING WRITING AWARDS FOR YOUNG PEOPLE ANNOUNCED
15 April 2009
2009 WILLS WRITING AWARDS - Final Judging
24 March 2009
RECORD ENTRY FOR WILLS WRITING AWARDS
03 March 2009
ELIGIBILITY
13 February 2009
2009 WRITING AWARDS FOR UNDER 26s/19s/15s
16 January 2009
FEEDBACK TO ENTRANTS OF THE 2008 WILLS WRITING AWARDS
16 April 2008
2008 WINNERS OF HORSE-RACING WRITING AWARDS FOR YOUNG PEOPLE ANNOUNCED
16 April 2008
FEEDBACK FOR WILLS WRITING AWARDS ENTRANTS 2007
07 April 2007
2007 WINNERS OF HORSE-RACING WRITING AWARDS FOR YOUNG PEOPLE ANNOUNCED
05 April 2007
A LETTER FROM BROUGH SCOTT TO ALL PARTICIPANTS IN THE 2006 COMPETITION
12 April 2006
2006 WINNERS OF HORSE-RACING WRITING AWARDS FOR UNDER 26s AND UNDER 19s ANNOUNCED
10 April 2006
WINNERS OF HORSE-RACING WRITING AWARDS FOR UNDER 26s AND UNDER 19s ANNOUNCED
12 April 2005
WINNERS OF HORSE-RACING WRITING AWARDS FOR UNDER 26s AND UNDER 19s ANNOUNCED
08 April 2005
2004 AWARD WINNERS ANNOUNCED
08 October 2004

Newsletter Subscribe

Please enter your email below to subscribe to our Newsletter where you will recieve information in every thing to do with the Martin Wills Writing Awards.

Twitter Feed

Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Facebook